Sunday, April 25, 2010

The Tale of Squirrel Nutkin

Tyson brought home a new book from school last week. It is called "The Tale of Squirrel Nutkin," by Beatrix Potter. It's part of a new springtime literacy unit in his first grade class.

Now, I know this will shock you, but I am not all that familiar with Beatrix Potter's work. I know she wrote in the early 1900's, and I think we maybe read "The Tale of Peter Rabbit" when I was in elementary school (probably around Easter time... when the word "Easter" was still allowed to be uttered in public schools), but that's it. I knew she wrote a series of tales about cute woodland creatures, but I never read any of them. Until this Nutkin character came into our home and stirred up some discussion.

The book has quite a few pages, with quite a few words. Tyson has some... difficulty in school, and it's definitely too long for him. Plus, some of the words aren't American-English as much as they are British-English, so we have to keep stopping to explain what those words mean. Tyson is definitely not crazy about this assignment, so it's controversial for that reason.

But there is another reason it's a bit on the controversial side as far as Matt & I are concerned. Have you read this story?

Well, it starts by introducing the squirrels, who live in the woods at the edge of a lake. In the middle of the lake is an island that is just loaded with trees and nut bushes, so the island is to these squirrels what Death by Chocolate is to me. They make little squirrel-sized rafts and sail across the lake to the island.

I know. "Wow," you're thinking at this point. "This is such a hugely controversial story. Squirrels. Building rafts. Yikes."

Hold on... I'm getting to the questionable part.

So. In the middle of the island is a hollow tree. And in the hollow tree lives an old owl. And I guess since he lives in the middle of the island (and probably also eats little creatures - like squirrels) he has jurisdiction over the whole island (and all the nuts on said island).

Are you ready? Because here is where I start to think this story maybe isn't so cool.

The squirrels bring offerings to the owl. Offerings in the form of mice and fat moles, among other things. Offerings to appease the owl. So he will let them gather nuts from the island.

And, cue idolatry music. (Is there such a thing as "idolatry music?")

They reverently gather in a semi-circle around the owl who sits in his doorway. And they place three mice on the stone at his feet. And he takes the mice inside and the squirrels gather nuts and go home.

And this happens for six days.

And where is Nutkin in all this? Well, he's a very rude little squirrel who, if you ask me, needs to have his back porch turned red. If ya know what I'm saying.

He does not treat the owl with reverence or respect. He skitters around singing weird songs and asking riddles (which are ignored by the owl). Nutkin gets progressively worse each day, until the last day when he jumps onto the owl's head. The owl grabs him and sticks him in his waistcoat pocket. Then he takes him inside, holding him by his tail to "skin him," but Nutkin pulls so hard that his tale breaks in two and the little stinker gets away.

And how does the story end? Does Nutkin learn his lesson? Does he repent or apologize or teach the younger squirrels about proper manners?

He does not.

The book ends by telling us that to this day, if anyone asks Nutkin a riddle, he will turn around and have a little temper tantrum and bark at the animal asking the riddle.

Well then.

"The Tale of Squirrel Nutkin" is a tail of animal sacrifice, idolatry and a little squirrel with no manners, who ends up with post traumatic stress and rage issues.

Yes, these are just the underlying theme of the book. But we are diligent parents, and are concerned with those subtle, underlying messages that sneak in under the radar.

Thank goodness Tyson doesn't really like this book... he doesn't really pay attention to what is being read. He just wants to get through it, and in this instance I'm okay with that.

Have you read the Tale of Squirrel Nutkin?" What did you think of it?


  1. I love you, you purple girl!
    Beatrix is my hero!
    But you know, like those old silly folk songs and nursery rhymes...(when the wind blows the cradle will fall...) sometimes I too wonder about the stories they came up with!
    Truth to tell, if the authors of old lived in our day and age and watched 15 minutes of our tv, they would surely wonder what in the world we are putting into our kids heads!

  2. Ahhh, yes... but that is why my kids don't watch much TV! My favorite old song is "Ring Around the Rosies" - it's about the Black Plague!

  3. I know it. We don't watch tv here. Just movies. But even some of those can be "nutkinney"...
    We should be choosy about what comes into our homes. When it comes in, seeps in, or just originates within we find it out, and expose it. You are right, and God's Spirit will lead you to see truth. We should implore them to find the fallacies and misconceptions. Make it a challenge.

  4. I'm still wondering what the moral of the story is supposed to be. I mean, if he had learned his lesson and did all the good things you said, then I can see it being a worthwhile book to read. But the way it is, (and this is a stretch coming from a bibliophile like myself) I see no inherent worth in the story.
    I'm still having nightmares about the animal sacrifice offerings at the owl's altar. Shivers.
    I agree, let Ty skim over this one and go on to read more positive, worthwhile books!


I would love to hear from you (as long as you're not a robot.)!